Wednesday 28 June 2017

"Italo-Flemish" work is copy after Abraham Bloemaert

Hampel, from Germany, sells on 5 July 2017 an "Italo Flemish painter, 17th century" The Golden Age, estimated at 20,000 to 30,000 Euro.

In the German description, they tell us "The representation is also found in a similar way in the work of Abraham Bloemaert (1564-1651). On the other hand, the depiction of the nudes is due to Venetian painting."

To be more precise, the work is a copy after a beautiful 1603 drawing by Abraham Bloemaert, not just something"similar". It is a nice copy, though I don't see the Italian connection. 

Some aspects of the explanation are alo unsatisfactory, e.g. "the dog lying undisturbed is shown beside a peacock, a symbol of peace among animals". Not really, that would be depicted by a lion some other fearsome predator and a lamb. The peacock, casting his shadow right at the front, is a symbol of the vanity and the folly, which is what this painting is really about: not just a "Golden Age", but a warning against vanity, debauchery, lust, with Time abiding his, well, time. 

The work by Bloemaert was often copied and wa more widely known through an engraving by Nicolaas de Bruyn from 1604. The painting here is not in the same direction as the reversed engraving, but oriented as the original was, so it may be based directly on the original drawing, or on one of the other copies. 

According to the text in the Sotheby's catalogue accompanying another copy, sold in 2016 for $10,000, there probably was no original painting, only an original drawing.

The work for sale is somewhat less faithful to the original, especially in the background. It is also a very large copy, 114 by 174 cm (e.g. the Sotheby's one wsa only 44 by 69 cm). It will probably easily fetch the estimate. But why they hid the connection to Bloemaert in the desscription is not really clear, if a work is a copy just say so, don't bury it in the text somewhere.

1 comment:

  1. Thanks for this!
    Besides Sotheby's or Hampel, one find's a small copy (18,5 x 9,5 cm) of the Bloemart drawing, described as "antique painting Greek mythology" on https://www.ricardo.ch/de/a/antikes-gemaelde-griechische-mythologie-1197942294/, no more information, but relatively low price therefore (450 USD) – that's also a district of online auctions, the one for bargains, presumably outside the Augur's radar ;)

    ReplyDelete